Episode 359: It’s Not the Line, It’s the Life: The Art of Authentic Communication with Jennifer Gardner
Authentic Communication Starts With Showing Up as Yourself Most of us have sat in a meeting at some point and…
Authentic Communication Starts With Showing Up as Yourself
Most of us have sat in a meeting at some point and wondered whether what we have to say even matters. Maybe you’ve thought, nobody cares what I think anyway. If that sounds familiar, I want you to know that it matters. Better yet, there’s a way to share your ideas, your projects, and your offers so people want to hear them. That’s what authentic communication is all about, and it’s something you can learn.
My guest, Jennifer Gardner, is a Los Angeles trial lawyer who has run her own firm for more than 30 years. Early on, she kept getting the cases nobody else wanted because they were supposedly unwinnable. Then she kept winning them, without any training in how to persuade. It took her years to understand what came so naturally to her. Now she teaches it through her Influence Amplifier Method™.
This is one of the longest episodes we’ve ever aired. I almost cut it in half, and then I decided this is one conversation you need to absorb all the way through. With the holidays coming up, it might even help with that Uncle Bob you don’t always love talking to. Pop in those earphones, and let’s get to it.
In this episode, you’ll hear:
- How Jennifer went from getting the message to “shut up” to winning case after case in front of juries
- Why being alive includes your fear and self-doubt, not just the happy parts
- How something as simple as putting your feet on the floor and breathing helps your presence
- What horses can teach us about reading emotions, and why they can tell when someone is faking calm
- Why feelings, not data and logic, drive most of our decisions
- The acting coach story behind “It’s not the line, it’s the life”
- How the Pratfall Effect turns small mistakes into trust
- Why certainty runs even deeper than confidence
- How self-regulation keeps you steady when someone throws word salad at you
Listen to the Full Episode
Watch the Full Episode
How Jennifer Learned That Her Voice Matters
When I asked Jennifer why she chose this work for her life, she went back to her childhood. Growing up, she got the message that the way she saw things was wrong. She called out things nobody wanted called out, and she got the message to shut up. At the same time, she got the message to get a professional degree and become a lawyer.
So she did. Unfortunately, the senior partner at her first law firm didn’t want her there. In fact, he told her she would never go anywhere in the legal profession. It was one more message that what she had to say didn’t matter.
Winning the Cases Nobody Wanted
Later, after some illness in the family, she started her own practice because she needed a job. This was before the internet, so she networked two or three times a day, suiting up and showing up. In return, other lawyers handed her the awful cases no sane lawyer would take. They didn’t even want a referral fee.
Then she found herself in court with no mentorship, no training, and no idea how to try a case. And she started winning case after case. Somehow, a room of strangers who didn’t want to be there kept believing her and wanting to help her clients.
After about 20 years of winging it, Jennifer decided it was time to get some training. She studied advanced trial skills, and then the neuroscience and psychology of persuasion. Along the way, she noticed that marketers knew things about persuasion that nobody was teaching lawyers, or a lot of leaders. That’s why she now teaches authentic communication, especially to heart-centered, purpose-driven people who want to do good in the world but don’t yet know how to show up.
Why We’re All Hungry for Authentic Communication
According to Jennifer, our culture has become isolated. We’re afraid to communicate with each other because we’re afraid of triggering each other. When she said that, I told her it sounds like we’re ready for Society 2.0. Can we start being people again and come back to each other, please?
Jennifer is already working on it. Recently, she hosted an in-person event in her garden called The Nerve Lab. She invited people who didn’t know each other, and the invitation simply said, “Be brave, skip the small talk, tell stories that matter.” The rules were no politics and no judgments. When you shared, you only shared what someone else’s story brought up for you. As a result, she created psychological safety and discomfort at the same time, and people opened up about some very serious things.
It makes sense. We have all these tools that are supposed to bring us closer, and yet we don’t go see each other anymore. For Jennifer, being in front of people you don’t know is a performance, so you’re automatically vulnerable. That vulnerability has always flipped a switch for her. It helps her connect with herself at a deeper level, and that’s what people feel. When you practice authentic communication on purpose, your connection, your influence, and your leadership all grow from there.
Authentic Communication Includes the Dark and the Light
There’s performing, and then there’s performing from a solid grounding inside yourself. People can tell the difference. Someone who’s hollow or just performing feels very different from someone comfortable in their own skin.
I call it consciousness. It’s why I teach wealth consciousness, because consciousness is really focused attention. It’s being alive. Think about the moments in your life you remember the most. You were conscious in them, and that’s why they felt so good.
Jennifer wanted to come back to that word, alive, because so many of us get it wrong.
“What I think a lot of people get wrong about aliveness is they think that it’s all happy and all good and all confident and all knowing and all-powerful and all-righteous, and it’s not. Aliveness is a combination of the dark and the light.” — Jennifer Gardner

So the self-doubt, the fear, the anxiety, the stress, and the worry all belong in the conversation too. Don’t deny it, don’t suppress it, and don’t water it down. That’s what makes authentic communication authentic. That’s why I say consciousness is the opposite of all that toxic positivity stuff out there. It’s being 100% here for what’s happening right now.
People always ask me why people spend money. My answer is consciousness and aliveness.
“That’s why I always feel so bad for people who only have money, because they buy all that stuff hoping it’ll make them feel alive. Hoping they’ll finally be there.” — Sarah Walton
Why Authentic Communication Takes Courage
The aliveness was never in the stuff. It’s inside us.
Bringing that aliveness into your communication takes some courage, though. You have to be ready to deal with the uncomfortable situation, whether it’s the conversation you’ve been avoiding or the fear inside you. According to Jennifer, the only way to transmute it is to go into it and confront it.
She learned a lot about this from riding horses. In a second, a horse can snap into prey mode and go sideways. You’d better be present and sitting on that horse right in that moment. For me, that’s how we stay inside wealth consciousness too. There’s a natural cycle happening in our lives all the time. We feel the self-doubt when we start believing something from the past or worrying about the future, and that’s when we interrupt the flow.
How Your Nervous System Shapes Authentic Communication
Jennifer says working with your nervous system is easier than it sounds. It’s something as basic as putting your feet on the floor and breathing. We’re wired to be afraid of a lot of things, so the first step is to normalize the fear, especially when you’re speaking in public.
By the way, Jennifer still gets nervous. She just has a lot of practice, which is the point. It’s like going to the gym. I was joking with my boyfriend recently that health isn’t an event, and your nervous system isn’t an event either. It’s an ongoing practice of calming, breathing, and taking care of yourself.
Jennifer also went to acting school, where she learned the importance of slowing down, breathing, getting in your body, and feeling. Then you hold the thought, keep presenting, and allow whatever’s coming up in you. These are the skills behind authentic communication, and anyone can learn them.
She laughed that she’s leaned on the word neuroscience a lot because she got so excited learning about things like mirror neurons. When she projects a feeling, other people feel it and send it back to her. Still, what she’s really talking about is something incredibly human that we all live every day.
“Getting centered in yourself and understanding what you are feeling, because when you understand that, you can understand what another person is feeling. It’s like the gateway to empathy. It starts with yourself.” — Jennifer Gardner

What Horses Know About Authenticity
There are universal feelings, like pain, surprise, affection, fear, and love. Jennifer learned to read them in horses, especially her own horse, Cowboy, who’s a retired movie horse and a real character.
I’d heard that horses won’t respond to something that isn’t real. If you pretend to be calm when you’re not, the horse won’t come near you. Jennifer explained why. Horses are prey animals, so that part of their brain is highly developed. They can tell whether a mountain lion nearby is hungry or just had dinner.
People pick up on our cues the same way. It happens on an unconscious level, but it still registers and affects how they feel. That’s one more reason authentic communication matters so much.
Why Authentic Communication Speaks to Feelings First
One of the things Jennifer learned from neuroscientists explains a lot about why authentic communication works.
“Feelings are the primary way that the human mind makes a decision. So we decide more based on how we feel about something than on data and logic.” — Jennifer Gardner
When I teach sales, I always say every single purchase is emotional. The same goes for who we choose to believe. Think about meeting someone at a party who says all the nice things and walks away, and you feel like you just got slimed. They said the right words, and still, something was way off.
The Influence Amplifier Method: Five Pillars of Authentic Communication
Jennifer calls her method I.A.M. It starts with being really present when you communicate so that you can connect with the people in front of you. That’s easier said than done, and she works on it constantly. Her way in is to get in touch with her own fear and sense of not-enoughness. Then, boom, she’s there.
That’s the shared humanity piece. Everyone on planet Earth has some version of “I’m afraid I’m dumb.” When we can be with the realness of that, everybody can be best friends.
Jennifer also hears from people who say they’re introverted or shy. They see what’s wrong and how to fix it, but they’re nervous to speak up in the meeting or confront the client. According to Jennifer, that discomfort is largely a function of our beliefs about who we are and our identities. So much of her work is opening people’s eyes to those beliefs so they understand they’re not defective and their voice matters.
Pillar 1: Prepare Yourself
When I first heard about this pillar, I thought it meant memorizing your lines. That’s part of it, of course. But Jennifer means the mindset before you speak. What unconscious beliefs do you hold about whether you’re worthy of being listened to? What value do you have to offer, and what courage do you need to say what you need to say? It’s the most important step, and it’s the one they don’t teach in business school or law school.
She also shared a concept from author Herminia Ibarra: we show up how we believe we’re showing up. To shift how others see us, we have to shift the identity within ourselves first. As Jennifer put it, “I am powerful. I am influential. I am worthy of being heard, and my ideas matter.” That’s the foundation for authentic communication and everything else she teaches.
Even the people we see as naturally polished have fear and doubts. They’ve trained themselves to go for it anyway, and they usually have the best coaching money can buy.
The Acting Coach Story Behind “It’s Not the Line, It’s the Life”
Jennifer also told a story she read years ago about famous acting coach Stella Adler. At one performance of a play, two-thirds of the audience walked out at intermission and never came back. At a second performance, the audience stayed for the whole thing and gave the actors a standing ovation. When someone asked Stella Adler what made the difference, this was her answer:
“It’s not the line, it’s the life.” — Stella Adler, as shared by Jennifer Gardner
I want to make a bumper sticker out of that. As Jennifer pointed out, it’s what we’d been saying the whole conversation. It’s the amount of life. And remember, aliveness is all of it, including feeling afraid and nervous about how you’ll be received. If you leave out that part, you lack the authenticity you need to deliver the message.
Pillar 2: Build Rapport
People trust you more when you show up as yourself, which is the heart of authentic communication. However, Jennifer says there are also things you can do to help people like you. She hates to say it, but we need to be likable. If people don’t like us, they won’t listen to us or do anything with us.
One tool she uses is the Pratfall Effect. Generally speaking, the more status a person has, the more others distrust them. That’s especially helpful for women to understand, because the higher our status, the more we trigger the opposition. To counteract it, make small blunders instead of acting like you know everything.
For Jennifer, that part has always been easy in the courtroom. She’s always forgetting something, and she isn’t faking it. It just happens, and she keeps going. Don’t show up and be perfect. Who wants to hang out with someone who’s perfect?
Pillar 3: Trigger Emotion
This one is Jennifer’s favorite. All of her male mentors told her not to be emotional, and she called BS on that, because emotion is what works for her. I’m with her. Emotion is usually when you actually want to listen to somebody, and it’s a big part of authentic communication.
When her allergies make her eyes tear up in court, she tells the jury exactly that. She explains that when she’s crying, they’ll know it and feel it. Judges are trained not to listen to their emotions, but Jennifer knows how to get them to feel things anyway.
She also believes that to heal the country, we have to get into the emotions, not just the rage. That means the pain, the fear, and the hurt beneath it. I always like to point out that rage is actually a combination of two emotions: anger and shame. So when there’s rage, we know there’s pain.
“Your emotions matter. They are actually usually the gateway to happiness and to joy and to effectiveness and to persuasion. But we have to have the courage to access them and heal.” — Sarah Walton

Jennifer keeps a mental Rolodex of tools she can flip through to be more effective. Knowing they’re there boosts her confidence, and confidence is the name of the game. If people smell fear, it’s game over. I went one step deeper with her on that one.
“I think certainty is the key to life. Certainty that you will figure it out. Certainty in your tools. Certainty in your ability to access those… people know when they’re in the presence of someone who’s certain.” — Sarah Walton

Certainty is a little more humble than confidence. It has a stillness to it, like, yeah, I’m going to do this.
Pillar 4: Bring the Drama
This pillar is all about telling stories, one of the most natural forms of authentic communication. At my own in-person retreat, we got talking about historical fiction. Someone asked why school didn’t teach history through the stories of the humans. We would have remembered all of it.
Jennifer agrees. In fact, story is how she started speaking on bigger stages. In 2020, she ran webinars for professionals stuck at home who didn’t know what to say online to get business. She called it “What the F Do I Say?” That led to invitations to teach storytelling workshops for continuing legal education.
A Rooftop Lesson in Authentic Communication
Jennifer shared a story to show what this looks like in real life. She took her 89-year-old mother to dinner on the Peninsula Hotel’s rooftop in Beverly Hills. The man next to them wore a baseball hat with an American flag and a branch of the military on it, and Jennifer felt like she knew exactly who he was.
He turned out to be one of the warmest, nicest people she’s ever met. Toward the end of the night, he mentioned he’d been the CEO of a major company. They traded airplane stories, and when she told hers, he patted her on the back and called it the greatest story. There was generosity, confidence, competence, and certainty in him. When he and his wife left, she was sad to see them go. She would have followed that man anywhere.
I wanted Jennifer to take credit for that connection too. She could have gone with a stereotype and missed the person underneath. So many of us have been trained to see people through labels, and boy, are we missing out when we do that. And when someone presents with judgment, as if they already know who you are, that’s a message no one’s going to hear.
Pillar 5: Control the Frame
This pillar is about how you use language. The most basic version is “It’s not X, it’s Y.” You get people to see things your way by calling out what it’s not and emphasizing what it is.
Jennifer is also a big student of neuro-linguistic programming and language patterns. For example, asking questions helps you control the focus. Even the word “because” gets people leaning in to hear the reason. Once you start noticing these patterns, you can’t unsee them.
Self-Regulation Keeps Authentic Communication Steady
The other piece of controlling the frame is self-regulation. Lately, Jennifer’s law practice has brought her a lot of high-conflict people, and she thinks it’s there to show her something.
“So much of leadership is self-regulation because you are being called upon to handle problems and deal with things all day long, every day.” — Jennifer Gardner
These days, Jennifer says about 85% of her job is self-regulation. If she reacts, she falls into the other side’s word chaos and word salad, and her client’s position suffers. So when a pleading comes in, and she’s thinking, what is this nonsense, she doesn’t say that in court. Instead, she says, “That’s so interesting. So let me ask you something.”
It’s the same in parenting. When a teenager says, “I hate you,” the best parents say, “Great, dinner’s at six.” That’s the skill. When you’re truly alive and present, you can watch someone throw word salad at you and keep going.
The key to delivering a message people want to hear is the amount of life behind it. So take your emotion, your truth, your honesty, and your lively nature into every conversation you have over the next several weeks. Jennifer’s free guide below is a great place to start practicing authentic communication.
About Jennifer Gardner
Jennifer Gardner is a Los Angeles-based trial lawyer, persuasive communication educator, and speaker. For more than 30 years, she has run her own law firm, litigating complex business, real estate, and criminal cases, using neuro and cognitive science-backed communication skills to achieve favorable outcomes for her clients. Jennifer also advises attorneys on strategic messaging, leadership, and executive presence in the courtroom.
As the founder of The Edge Education, Jennifer teaches high-performing executives how to lead with confidence, influence decision-makers, and communicate effectively under pressure using emotional intelligence and her communication toolkit, The Influence Amplifier Method.
Jennifer holds certifications from The Wharton School in Executive Presence and Influence: Persuasive Leadership Development, and Understanding the Brain: Using Neuroscience to Deliver Better Business Results. She is a graduate of the Trial Lawyers College and the Gerry Spence Method.
Connect with Jennifer
- Website: jenniferbgardner.com
- Instagram: @iamjenniferbgardner
- LinkedIn: Jennifer B. Gardner
Jennifer’s Free Gift for Girlfriends
Want to stay composed, command the room, and influence outcomes when the stakes are high? Jennifer’s Empathic Power Players Communication Survival Guide is your blueprint for exactly that. It’s a practical way to start using what she teaches in your next meeting, pitch, or hard conversation.
Related Episodes You’ll Love
Episode 283: How to Find Your Signature Talk With Speaking Coach Jen Oliver — TEDx executive producer and speaking coach Jen Oliver shares how to find the signature talk that connects with your audience. If Jennifer got you thinking about stepping on a bigger stage, start here. Listen here
Episode 325: Brand Voice for Women Entrepreneurs: Stop Performing and Start Attracting Your People with Patricia Viscount — Patricia helps coaches and consultants find their genuine brand voice, so content flows easier, and the right clients find you. It’s a natural next listen if you want to stop editing yourself out of your own business. Listen here
Episode 232: Storytelling, Sharing With Clients and Taylor Swift with Christine DeHerrera — Writer and coach Christine DeHerrera talks about storytelling and shares tips so you can start sharing your own stories. If you loved Jennifer’s “Bring the Drama” pillar, you’ll enjoy this one. Listen here
Let’s Talk About Your Business
If you’re ready to grow your income and build real wealth in your business, let’s talk. As my gift to Girlfriends, I offer a free 30-minute discovery call. Together, we’ll look at where you are right now and what might be getting in the way.
Connect with Sarah
- Instagram: @thesarahwalton
- LinkedIn: Sarah Walton
- Free resources for you
- Join the Game On Girlfriend® community — subscribe to the podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or YouTube
Love This Episode?
If you know a woman who has something important to say and keeps holding back in meetings, send this episode her way. It might be the reminder she needs that her voice matters.
About Sarah Walton
Sarah Walton is a wealth consciousness coach, strategic advisor, and the host of the Game On Girlfriend® podcast. Her mission is simple: to put more money in the hands of more women. She helps women entrepreneurs build profitable, sustainable businesses without burnout — working through both the mindset and the strategy sides of growth. Because when women have more financial power, they don’t just keep it — they use it to take care of their families, support their communities, and build something bigger than themselves. Through her programs — including the Abundance Academy and The Art of Receiving — along with her online courses and one-on-one coaching, Sarah works with women who are ready to build profitable businesses and use that financial power to make a real difference in the world around them.
Binge More Game On Girlfriend™ Podcast Episodes
EP
Episode 358: Money Codes and How to Attract More Money, with Julie Foucht
Money Is Energy, and You’re Allowed to Have a Lot of It…
Play Episode
• Audio
EP
Episode 357: You Don’t Need More Time, You Need Better Support — Gina Cotner on Delegation
Why Delegation Gives You Your Life Back After more than 17 years…
Play Episode
• Audio
EP
Episode 356: The Soul Contract vs. the Achievement Wound — Three Questions to Ask Before You Quit
Soul Contract or Pushing Water Uphill? How to Know Before You Quit…
Play Episode
• Audio
It’s Time To Plan For Profit!
Freedom Calculator
Download my FREEDOM CALCULATOR and discover how much your business needs to make so you can finally be FREE.
Learn the exact number you need to feel free
Know what you need to do daily to make more money
Know what you need to do daily to make more money
Avoid the most common mistakes business owners make
It’s time to move from “fingers crossed” to clear and successful.